Foreign University Campuses in India: A Critical Analysis

The recent proposal by the University Grants Commission (UGC) to allow foreign universities to set up campuses in India has sparked a lively debate among educators and policymakers, whose supporters and opponents hold different views. The draft norms announced by UGC suggest that foreign universities can decide their admission process and fee structure and repatriate funds to their parent campuses. 

However, there are also concerns that the entry of foreign universities may have negative consequences for the Indian higher education system. It's crucial to weigh the pros and cons of this move as the norms are in the draft stage and open to suggestions and objections from the public.

Arguments in Favor of UGC's Move

1. Wider Educational Opportunities

One of the main arguments in favour of allowing foreign universities to set up campuses in India is that it would provide Indian students with access to a broader range of educational opportunities. 

According to the Institute of International Education (IIE), in 2019-20, over 200,000 Indian students studied in foreign universities, making India the second largest sender of international students after China. With foreign universities setting up campuses in India, students will have more options to pursue higher education without leaving the country.

2. Raising the Standard of Higher Education

Another argument in favour of foreign universities in India is that it would raise the standard of education in the country. According to the World Bank, India's investment in education as a percentage of GDP is 4.4%, which is lower than the global average of 5%. With the competition from foreign universities, the existing Indian universities would be forced to improve the quality of their education to attract students. This would lead to a general improvement in the standard of higher education in the country.

3. Boosting the economy

The presence of foreign universities in India would also boost the Indian economy. According to a report by the Confederation of Indian Industry (CII), the education sector in India is valued at $91 billion and is projected to reach $101 billion by 2020. With foreign universities setting up campuses in India, it would attract students from other countries to come to India for their higher education, thereby boosting the Indian economy.

Critics Pointers:

1. Dilution of quality of education

 One of the main concerns is that it would lead to a dilution of the quality of education in the country. With foreign universities focused on making a profit, there is a fear that they would compromise on the quality of education to attract more students. Additionally, there is also a concern that foreign universities would not be as responsive to the needs of the Indian higher education system compared to Indian universities.

Nearly 40% of Indian professors are considering moving to foreign universities.

2. Lack of focus on the needs of the Indian Education

Another concern is that it would lead to a lack of focus on the needs of the Indian higher education system. With foreign universities focused on their interests, there is a fear that they would not consider the specific needs of the Indian higher education system. This could lead to a mismatch between the education provided by foreign universities and the needs of the Indian job market.

How will the Existing Colleges and Universities be affected? 

• The influx of foreign campuses could lead to a significant loss of good faculty from existing HEIs, with a report from the Confederation of Indian Industry (CII) stating that nearly 40% of Indian professors are considering moving to foreign universities. 
• Foreign campuses could also exacerbate the existing socio-economic divide in education with their high tuition fees. Additionally, they may be exempted from providing reservations, potentially widening the gap between underprivileged and privileged students.

Indian HEIs Need to Revamp Their Legacy; Here's How?

upGrad Campus can help colleges and universities strengthen their infrastructure and quality of delivery through

• Industry-relevant programs: giving students the employment-ready skills to face the challenges of a changing workplace. 
• New-age specializations: aligning with the current trends and demands of the job market, helping improve the employability of graduates. 
• Data-driven insights: providing data-driven insights on student performance and engagement, which can help colleges to identify areas for improvement and track progress over time.
• Cutting-edge infrastructure: Lecture Capture System, Blended and Live classrooms to help colleges improve the quality of education and student engagement. For more details on our offering, click here or visit our website.

In conclusion, the decision to allow foreign universities to set up campuses in India is complex and needs to be weighed carefully. While there are certainly benefits to be gained from foreign universities setting up in India, there are also concerns that need to be addressed. Therefore, Indian Higher Education Institutions (HEIs) should start taking this matter seriously and proactively prepare themselves to stay ahead in the market.